Identity in Medicine: Proud Medicine

Identity in medicine transcends the conventional notion of verifying credentials and authorizations. It encompasses the multifaceted identities that medical professionals bring into their practice, shaped by their characteristics, relationships, experiences, and the broader social and cultural context. For LGBTQ medical students and residents, their journey is marked by the dual navigation of their professional roles and personal identities in a field that has traditionally been conservative and heteronormative.

LGBTQ Identity in Medicine

For LGBTQ medical students and residents, the intersection of personal and professional identities presents unique challenges and opportunities. These individuals not only face the rigorous demands of medical training but also contend with societal attitudes and institutional biases related to their sexual orientation and gender identity. This duality shapes their experiences in profound ways, impacting their mental health, professional development, and overall well-being.

The medical community has long been seen as a bastion of traditional values, where professionalism is often conflated with conformity to heteronormative standards. LGBTQ individuals, therefore, often find themselves navigating an environment where their identity might not always be fully accepted or understood. This can lead to feelings of isolation, stress, and the constant pressure to conform to a professional identity that does not fully represent their true selves.

Professional Identity and Personal Authenticity

Medical professionals are expected to uphold certain duties, responsibilities, and behaviors, forming a collective identity defined by societal norms and the medical community’s standards. For LGBTQ individuals, maintaining authenticity while meeting these expectations can be particularly challenging. The medical profession often emphasizes objectivity, detachment, and a uniform code of conduct, which can clash with the personal experiences and identities of LGBTQ individuals.

Authenticity in medicine refers to the ability of healthcare providers to bring their whole selves to their practice. For LGBTQ medical students and residents, this means being able to express their gender identity and sexual orientation without fear of discrimination or prejudice. Unfortunately, many still feel the need to conceal aspects of their identity to fit into the perceived mold of a “good doctor.” This concealment can have detrimental effects on their mental health and job satisfaction.

Historical Context of Identity in Medicine

The concept of identity in medicine has evolved significantly from ancient philosophies to modern-day practices. In ancient Greece, medicine was deeply intertwined with magic and religious rites, managed by priests who developed specialized knowledge. This period marked the beginning of viewing medicine as both an art and a science, with a focus on the holistic understanding of health and illness.

As medical science progressed, particularly during the Enlightenment and the subsequent Industrial Revolution, the professional identity of physicians became more defined. Medicine began to be seen as a distinct and rigorous field of study, characterized by scientific inquiry and evidence-based practice. However, this professionalization often excluded marginalized groups, including LGBTQ individuals, whose identities were not considered in the mainstream discourse of medical education and practice.

The 20th and 21st centuries have seen significant advancements in both medical science and the understanding of human identity. The civil rights movements, including LGBTQ rights, have influenced how we view diversity and inclusion within the medical community. Despite these advancements, the medical field still grapples with deeply ingrained biases and stereotypes that affect LGBTQ individuals.

The Impact of Identity on Medical Training

Medical training is a formative period where students and residents develop their professional identities. For LGBTQ individuals, this period can be particularly challenging due to the additional layer of navigating their identity in a potentially unwelcoming environment. Studies have shown that LGBTQ medical students often face higher levels of stress, burnout, and mental health issues compared to their heterosexual and cisgender peers. 

The hidden curriculum in medical schools, which includes the implicit messages and cultural norms conveyed to students, can significantly impact the experiences of LGBTQ individuals. This hidden curriculum often perpetuates heteronormativity and gender binarism, making it difficult for LGBTQ students to feel fully included and supported. Microaggressions, discrimination, and lack of representation in the curriculum are common issues that LGBTQ medical students face. 

Support Systems and Coping Mechanisms

Support systems are crucial for the well-being of LGBTQ medical students and residents. Many institutions have started to recognize the importance of creating inclusive environments and have established LGBTQ support groups, mentorship programs, and resource centers. These initiatives provide safe spaces for LGBTQ individuals to share their experiences, seek advice, and find solidarity with others who face similar challenges. 

Mentorship is important in medical education, particularly so for LGBTQ medical students and residents. Having a mentor who understands their unique challenges and can provide guidance and support can make a significant difference in their professional and personal development. Mentors can also help navigate the complexities of being out in the medical field and advocate for more inclusive policies and practices within their institutions. 

In addition to institutional support, individual coping mechanisms play a vital role in managing the stress and challenges associated with being an LGBTQ medical professional. These coping mechanisms can include building a strong social network, engaging in self-care practices, and seeking therapy or counseling when needed. LGBTQ individuals need to prioritize their mental health and well-being to thrive both personally and professionally.

The Role of Allies and Advocacy

Allies play a crucial role in creating inclusive environments for LGBTQ medical professionals. Allies are individuals who support and stand up for the rights of LGBTQ individuals, helping to create a more accepting and equitable environment. In the medical field, allies can be colleagues, mentors, educators, and institutional leaders who actively work to challenge discrimination and promote diversity and inclusion..

Advocacy for LGBTQ rights within the medical community involves both systemic changes and individual actions. At the systemic level, medical institutions must implement policies that explicitly protect LGBTQ individuals from discrimination and provide comprehensive training on LGBTQ issues for all staff and students. Curriculum reforms are also necessary to ensure that LGBTQ health is adequately covered and that diverse identities are represented in medical education..

At the individual level, programs can do more to support the academic progress of LGBTQ+ students, including earlier referral to programs like LAS, when the student begins to struggle. Allies can take steps to create a more inclusive environment by using inclusive language, challenging discriminatory behavior, and actively supporting LGBTQ colleagues. Simple actions, such as using correct pronouns and acknowledging the unique experiences of LGBTQ individuals, can make a significant difference in fostering a culture of acceptance and respect.

Case Studies and Success Stories

Highlighting case studies and success stories of LGBTQ medical professionals can serve as powerful examples of resilience and achievement. These stories can inspire current and future LGBTQ medical students and residents by showing that it is possible to succeed in the medical field while being true to oneself.

One notable example is Dr. Rachel Levine, the first openly transgender federal official confirmed by the U.S. Senate. Her career as a pediatrician and public health advocate, combined with her visibility as a transgender woman, has made her a role model for many LGBTQ individuals in medicine. Dr. Levine’s success demonstrates the importance of representation and the impact that LGBTQ individuals can have on the medical community and beyond.

Another example is Dr. Scout, the Executive Director of the National LGBT Cancer Network. As a transgender man, Dr. Scout has been a leading advocate for LGBTQ health, particularly in the field of cancer prevention and care. His work has helped to address the unique health disparities faced by LGBTQ individuals and has highlighted the importance of culturally competent care. 

These stories, among many others, underscore the potential for LGBTQ medical professionals to make significant contributions to the field while also advocating for greater inclusivity and representation.

Creating a more inclusive medical community involves recognizing and embracing the diverse identities of its members. LGBTQ medical students and residents bring unique perspectives and strengths to the field, enriching the practice of medicine with their experiences and insights. By fostering an environment that supports their authentic selves, the medical community can enhance both personal well-being and professional excellence.

It is essential for medical institutions to actively work towards inclusivity by implementing supportive policies, providing comprehensive training on LGBTQ issues, and promoting a culture of acceptance and respect. Allies and advocates play a crucial role in this process, helping to challenge discrimination and create a more equitable environment for all.

In embracing the diversity of identities within medicine, we move closer to a healthcare system that truly serves and represents all individuals, ensuring that everyone, regardless of their sexual orientation or gender identity, can thrive both as professionals and as individuals. 

References

1. Association of American Medical Colleges. “The Hidden Curriculum in Academic Medicine: Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity.” (November 2015). AAMC Videos and Resources. Washington, DC: Association of American Medical Colleges. 
2. Dunn LK, Pham E, Kabil E, Kleiman AM, Hilton EJ, Lyons GR, Ma JZ, Nemergut EC, Forkin KT. The Impact of Physician Race and Sex on Patient Ranking of Physician Competence and Perception of Leadership Ability. Cureus. 2023 Feb 8;15(2):e34778. doi: 10.7759/cureus.34778. PMID: 36909083; PMCID: PMC10005834.
3. Prasad S, O’Malley CB, DeLeon R, Levy AS, Griffin DP. Inclusive LGBTQIA+ healthcare: An interprofessional case-based experience for cultural competency awareness. Front Public Health. 2023 Jan 4;10:993461. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2022.993461. PMID: 36684971; PMCID: PMC9846843.
4. Eliason, Michele & Dibble, Suzanne & Robertson, Patricia. (2011). Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender (LGBT) Physicians’ Experiences in the Workplace. Journal of homosexuality. 58. 1355-71. 10.1080/00918369.2011.614902.